83. Cultural Psychology - At the Edge of
Identity: Cultural Contexts and the Crisis Within
Today, many individuals living in immigrant
families, multicultural communities, or diasporic societies find the
question “Who am I?” increasingly complex.
When a new cultural layer is placed over traditional cultural roots,
the internal structure of identity becomes vulnerable to instability.
This post takes a deep psychological approach to the phenomenon of identity
crisis in specific cultural contexts,
exploring scientific theories, real-life cases, and strategies for reconnecting
with oneself.
1. Definition of Concepts
A. The Nature of Identity
Identity refers to the emotional assurance and cognitive recognition of
oneself—
a sense of “Who am I?” shaped through culture, language, and values.
Individuals define themselves and their relationships through this structure.
B. Meaning of Specific Cultural Contexts
A specific cultural context refers to a collective that shares values, norms,
language, and customs—
the foundation of one’s identity development.
Examples include Korean diaspora, repatriated migrants, and some indigenous
groups.
C. What Is an Identity Crisis?
An identity crisis occurs when the cultural components that construct identity
come into internal or social conflict,
causing psychological unease and a blurred sense of self.
This can lead to emotional pain, self-doubt, and a collapse in the sense of
belonging.
2. Scientific and Psychological
Background
A. Erikson’s Psychosocial Development
Theory
According to Erikson, individuals undergo identity crises in adolescence and
early adulthood
as they interact with social environments to explore and establish their
identities.
For children of immigrants who speak both their native and the host country’s
languages,
this process becomes longer and more complex.
Case Example:
A Korean-American teenager reported internal conflict,
constantly questioning whether they were Korean or American,
reflecting an ongoing identity struggle.
B. Cultural Confusion Theory
Those raised between two cultures often experience cultural confusion—
an uncertainty about which norms to apply in various social situations.
Case Example:
An Indian-Canadian woman experienced emotional distress
due to conflicting greeting customs and concepts of punctuality between her
family and friends.
This led to feelings of alienation and disconnection.
C. Self-Discrepancy Model
The greater the gap between one’s “ideal self” (what family or society expects)
and “actual self” (what one feels internally),
the more intense the identity crisis and accompanying psychological distress.
3. Core Psychological Mechanisms
A. Disrupted Sense of Belonging and
Isolation
Inability to integrate native and foreign cultural identities can
erode a sense of belonging, accelerating inner isolation and identity
confusion.
Case Example:
A second-generation Turkish student in Germany
reported skipping classes and undergoing therapy due to feelings of
alienation from both Turkish and German cultures.
B. Value Conflict and Loss of Self-Trust
Conflict between traditional family values and modern autonomy
often leads to indecisiveness and diminished trust in one’s own judgment.
Case Example:
A Korean university student struggled between their parents’ dream
of them becoming a civil servant and their own desire to be an artist,
leading to emotional paralysis.
C. Role Confusion and Reduced
Self-Efficacy
When expectations from different cultural norms clash,
individuals experience role ambiguity and a drop in self-efficacy.
Case Example:
A child from a multicultural household described confusion,
stating they felt like “a Korean student at home and a foreigner at school,”
leading to emotional fatigue and identity disorientation.
4. Behavioral and Cognitive Traits
A. Language Code-Switching
Frequent switching between languages and communication styles
may result in confusion about which identity is truly “authentic.”
B. Cultural Loneliness
Even when surrounded by others, individuals may feel
emotionally isolated with a deep sense of “belonging nowhere.”
C. Excessive Self-Monitoring
To avoid cultural misunderstandings, individuals may over-regulate their
behavior,
resulting in psychological exhaustion and heightened anxiety.
5. Strategies and Application Methods
A. Identity Journal Writing Programs
By encouraging individuals to confront their cultural confusion head-on,
“identity journaling” helps them express their inner experiences.
This process promotes emotional integration and self-clarity.
Application Example: In a program for multicultural adolescents,
writing ten minutes daily about “Who am I?” significantly reduced depression
scores
and improved clarity in self-concept.
B. Bicultural Competence Training
Programs designed for bicultural adolescents compare two cultures,
helping them reflect on their experiences and integrate aspects of both.
Exercise Examples: Drawing one’s family culture, ranking cultural values,
listing favorite and uncomfortable elements from each culture.
C. Group Counseling and Peer Mentoring
Group therapy with those experiencing identity crises and peer mentorship
sessions
foster self-reflection and strengthen social support networks.
6. Real-Life Case Studies
A. Identity Conflict of a Korean
American
K, a second-generation Korean American,
was expected to follow American values at school
and uphold Korean customs at home.
This dual pressure led to prolonged identity confusion.
In their late twenties, after taking a cultural psychology course and
spending time as an exchange student in Korea,
K developed a more integrated self-view and now works as a multicultural
education expert.
B. Value Conflict in a Maghreb Immigrant
in France
M, born in France to North African immigrant parents,
was raised with strict Islamic values at home and liberal European values
outside.
She suffered constant emotional conflict in career decisions,
feeling she had to “choose one culture over the other.”
Later, through exploring the idea of a hybrid identity,
she learned to embrace both worlds in a self-defined, harmonious way.
7. Enhancement or Resolution Methods
A. Applying the Integrated Self Model
Rather than choosing between identities,
individuals should be guided to synthesize all cultural influences
into a coherent, personal narrative.
B. Expanding Multicultural Acceptance
Education
Communities and schools should go beyond monocultural standards
and embrace educational models that foster identity sensitivity
and value diversity as a strength.
C. Specialized Psychological Counseling
for Identity Crisis
Therapies such as narrative therapy, identity mapping, and
cultural self-understanding dialogues can support identity
reconstruction,
not just solving immediate problems but nurturing self-acceptance and
resilience.
8. Implications
An identity crisis is not exclusive to
multicultural societies.
In today’s globalized world, everyone experiences cultural transitions and
intersections
that raise questions about who they are.
Rather than viewing these crises as disorders,
we must embrace them as evolutionary phases of self-exploration.
This shift in perspective transforms confusion into insight
and leads to deeper psychological maturity.
FAQ
Q. Is identity crisis temporary or
long-lasting?
It depends on the person. Some resolve it in adolescence,
while others may continue to face challenges through adulthood, especially in
changing environments.
Q. What’s the difference between
cultural and personal identity?
Cultural identity relates to social belonging,
while personal identity involves one’s emotional and cognitive self-conception.
Both are interlinked and mutually influential.
Q. Can identity crises be prevented?
Rather than prevention, it’s more effective to cultivate
flexible thinking and emotional regulation,
so individuals can adapt to identity shifts with resilience.
The Courage to Embrace Confusion, The
Path to Replanting Identity
An identity crisis is not a collapse—it is
a reconstruction.
Through this process, we revisit who we are and where we belong.
In navigating such crises, we begin building our “inner culture,”
discovering and defining our true selves through reflection and resilience.
Comments
Post a Comment